What We Like: Lovecraft Country

David Smith • Oct 16, 2019

Who are the real monsters?

The Author, with some bad tentacle photoshop work
Lovecraft Country

I’m not sure how to begin to talk about this book. It wasn’t anything like what I expected. Whilst I’ve not read any Lovecraft stories, I’ve played a lot of Fantasy Flight’s Arkham Files games. So, I’ve got a good handle on Elder Gods, portals to hellish dimensions, and 1920s archetypes. Turns out, a lot less so on Lovecraft's racism...

Turns out, LC is not that book. Instead, it’s an affecting, disturbing, and powerful take on racism and society in 1950s America. The paperback proudly proclaims the upcoming Jordan Peele/J.J. HBO adaptation, and you know what? That totally makes sense. It feels relevant, important and very current - like all good genre writing. And the tale it tells is pretty great too.

There's an undercurrent of otherworldly mysticism but to me, the book stays with me as a fierce reposte to that aforementioned H.P. racism. The truly chilling moments, for this reader at least, were the ones which featured the irrational hatred that the main characters have to live with, from other people. In the world around us, these terrible ideas of 'othering' seem to be making a comeback into mainstream dialogues which makes stories like these even more essential. 

I don't want to say too much about this one - the joy in discovering these rich and surprising characters, the way the book subverts tired tropes and assumptions about genre culture and who it's for - just go and discover it for yourselves. Then come back and tell me what you think

DS
by David Smith 10 Apr, 2020
Once I’d decided to run a festival, I started searching out new books, from authors I didn’t know, often picking up two or three in Waterstones or cheap on Amazon. Like a lot of readers, I had a good stable of authors I loved, most of whom were very prolific, so just keeping up with their output was pretty hard going. Away for work in Glasgow, I took advantage of a big Waterstones to buy three books I knew nothing about. I didn’t Google them in the shop, I didn’t make a note for later. Just read the backs and made a purchase. And I’m so glad I did, because in Feb/March of 2019 I read Rosewater. If you’re read my Ancillary Justice review you’ll know that I can be very late to the party so it was so pleasing to see this book win the Clarke Award this year. Rosewater is a dystopic novel, set in a future Nigeria, occupied by an alien. That might sound a bit like Caves of Steel but the tone, the feeling and the grittiness of the book is all it’s own. Tade Thompson creates a totally believable universe, where bad interests gather around exceptional events. If you've not read it, go and do so immediately, and then pick up the sequels. You're in for a treat!
by David Smith 16 Oct, 2019
Lovecraft Country I’m not sure how to begin to talk about this book. It wasn’t anything like what I expected. Whilst I’ve not read any Lovecraft stories, I’ve played a lot of Fantasy Flight’s Arkham Files games. So, I’ve got a good handle on Elder Gods, portals to hellish dimensions, and 1920s archetypes. Turns out, a lot less so on Lovecraft's racism... Turns out, LC is not that book. Instead, it’s an affecting, disturbing, and powerful take on racism and society in 1950s America. The paperback proudly proclaims the upcoming Jordan Peele/J.J. HBO adaptation, and you know what? That totally makes sense. It feels relevant, important and very current - like all good genre writing. And the tale it tells is pretty great too. There's an undercurrent of otherworldly mysticism but to me, the book stays with me as a fierce reposte to that aforementioned H.P. racism. The truly chilling moments, for this reader at least, were the ones which featured the irrational hatred that the main characters have to live with, from other people. In the world around us, these terrible ideas of 'othering' seem to be making a comeback into mainstream dialogues which makes stories like these even more essential. I don't want to say too much about this one - the joy in discovering these rich and surprising characters, the way the book subverts tired tropes and assumptions about genre culture and who it's for - just go and discover it for yourselves. Then come back and tell me what you think DS
by David Smith 22 Aug, 2019
I’m super aware that I’m VERY late to the party on AJ, and the work of Ann Leckie. It’s not for lack of interest. I even bought a copy of it for a friend (sight-unseen). I don’t know why I waited so long. It’s the first in a trilogy (I love trilogies), and it’s solid space opera (ditto). I just never got around to it somehow, until now. And the unsurprising TLDR? I was missing out. It’s great. Really good. One of my favourite things is that the world that Leckie describes, with its takes on gender, manners and power, is so unlike either the liberal, Utopian, narratives of progress, or the dystopic, male-centric takes of other writers I’ve read. It has subtlety in its world building that I like, a sense that things have been thought out. It’s somehow of the future, and old fashioned, which for a sci-fi fan and history graduate is catnip. Some reviews have noted the Roman Empire vibes AJ gives off, but I was much more reminded of stories of Victorian England/Empire, the delicacies of costume and manners (TBH the links with Imperial India are well noted elsewhere too). I wouldn’t doubt for a second that Victoria would have like 1,000 of her to rule her enormous empire and there’s a lot in there which could be compared with the British Raj. Those kinds of historical allusions, of course, mean that readers can play the game of trying to predict the plot against historical examples. I get the feeling though, that the next two books are going to be pleasingly unpredictable. The central character is also an intriguing one. As we approach the centenary of the first robots in RUR, it was great to be reminded of how far we’ve come that a “computer” can be part person, part machine, and somehow an uneasy hybrid of the two, not an android, something else. It’s a great character, and the twisted sense of self weaves well with the plot. The paperback book cover doesn’t shy away from the most striking literary comparison: Iain M. Banks. For me, Banks was my gateway into British SciFi of the 1980s and 1990s, with its swearing, sex, action and grittiness (and love of space opera). It’s a mark of my esteem of this book that Banks’ writing was my first comparison. Best thing about it? That world building, and that I know there are two more to read Who is this for? I assume I’m the last scifi fan to read it but if I’m not, this is a self-selecting one. If you’ve not read it yet and you’ve got this far…what are you waiting for? Further Reading https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/an-empire-divided/
Share by: